OK, so at the start of every new year, almost everyone says “I’m going to lose weight or get fit” or something. So I decided to see what this zero-calorie Monk Fruit In the Raw “all natural sweetener” is about.
The ingredients are: dextrose, monk fruit extract. In the larger bulk pack, the ingredients were: maltodextrin, monk fruit extract.
I wonder why the difference? I wonder what percentage of dextrose to monk fruit extract am I getting? Theoretically, they could simply add a few drops of the extract to the bin of dextrose and call it Monk Fruit in the Raw, but it is far from raw and since dextrose is the first ingredient, it is also far from being monk fruit.
So, I bought some to explore since I didn’t think the store would appreciate me trying this in the store. I opened a pack and poured it into my hand. I put some in my mouth and tasted it.
Sweet on the front, but it had an odd numbing sensation, slight, but numbing. Then the bitter after taste came on a few minutes after I had finished tasting the newly discovered miraculous ‘have your sweets and no calories too’ monk fruit sweetener. Yuck!
Then I put some in a perfectly good cup of coffee and totally ruined that too.
While the initial taste is sweet, it’s the dry bitterness of dextrose (yes another ‘natural’ sugar) that gets you in the end. Not being a diet soda drinker, I suppose my taste buds are more sensitive to those kind of flavors, but I didn’t like it at all. It actually numbed my taste receptors for a while after I finished tasting, that I didn’t like at all!
I read the website the claim “Has the least after taste . . .” but whats with that tongue coating effect?
After washing my tongue off and getting it back to normal, I tried the same with a bit of organic sugar. Yup! Pleasure, smooth and sweet.
So what’s the conclusion? Use sugar, just use a lot less. I’m learning to like my tea with no sweetener but Earl Grey really likes a small bit of sugar.
Unless you enjoy the sensation of diet/low-calorie food things in your mouth, stick to using sugar. Train yourself to use less. I know that’s not an option for diabetics., but maybe use the real fruit instead of this processed junk?
The packaging is romantic and describes the ancient history of using monk fruit as a sweet ingredient. I’d bet they didn’t have granulated sugar then either, let alone dextrose or maltodextrin to mix it with. What they used back then is not what is wrapped up so neatly in bright orange packages and presented to you as monk fruit.
And the zero calories? The say on the side of the box that each package contains less than 3 calories per serving which the FDA recognizes as zero calories. But whose counting?
This is my opinion and your tastes and experience may differ. I love that!
7 thoughts on “Monk Fruit in the Raw VS. Sugar”
I just saw this in the store and was so curious. Now I don’t have to waste my money. Thank you!
Don’t waste your money Heather, I hoped it would be different but nope!
Thanks for a great review, it is such an interesting product 😀
Thanks for this. I actually don’t mind the monk fruit flavor, but this morning I had a bowl of oatmeal with blueberries and one packet of monk fruit. My mouth and teeth became totally numb! So upon googling why that might be, I came across this. I’m glad to know I’m not the only one this happened to…I was afraid I might be allergic to blueberries!
I buy Lakanto monk fruit sweetener with erythritol, and it’s the closest thing to sugar I’ve ever tasted. I notice no aftertaste, although the erythritol does have a bit of a mouth-cooling effect, as do most – if not all – sugar alcohols. I like that, like sugar, if you over-sweeten something (a cup of tea, perhaps) there is sweetener left in the bottom of the cup, just as real sugar does. I’ve read many places that erythritol is the best non-sugar sweetener due to the fact that it is one of two (I think) sugar alcohols that has no effect on blood sugar, as others do in some people. It’s a bit expensive, but I’m worth it.
Just dealing with the numb tongue effect now since having monk fruit twice, once last night and then today within 24 hours, hope it passes soon! Will try cleaning my tongue as suggested…any other tips? This feeling is a worry!
I’d stop eating it.